Corporate Europe Observatory

Exposing the power of corporate lobbying in the EU

  • Dansk
  • NL
  • EN
  • FI
  • FR
  • DE
  • EL
  • IT
  • NO
  • PL
  • PT
  • RO
  • SL
  • ES
  • SV

Draghi and the Group of Thirty - an intro

Corporate Europe Observatory has demanded that the President of the European Central Bank Mario Draghi leaves the ‘Group of Thirty’, a club of central bankers and chief executives from private banks. Here we explore what the case is about and why the ECB's response is inadequate.

The methods of the financial lobby

The financial crisis in 2008 should have been a wake-up call. For many years the private financial sector has been allowed to set the agenda for financial regulation, in the US as well as in the EU. It ended in disaster. As a precautionary measure it is vital that central bankers and politicians keep a distance to the financial lobby. The Group of Thirty is a symbol that this is not the case.

What is the Group of Thirty?

The Group of Thirty is a club-like organisation whose members are central bankers and prominent bankers from big private banks such as Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan and UBS. It was set up to discuss global banking regulation – and to influence legislation.

A lobby group – not merely a think tank

The Group of 30 serves as an important interface between private bankers and central bankers. It’s not merely a place to discuss policy on banking, its stated aim is to have an impact on global regulation. On several occasions, the Group of 30 has come out in favour of proposals which are very similar to the positions put forward by the big private banks. This includes regulation of complicated financial instruments (derivatives) and rules on capital requirements for banks.

Draghi is a member

Mario Draghi has stepped back and forth between the worlds of public and private banking. He was previously a member of the Group of Thirty when working for Wall Street investment Bank, Goldman Sachs. Now he participates in the activities as President of The European Central Bank. The Group of Thirty regularly puts out reports on controversial issues, and its spokesperson (Jacob Frenkel, JP Morgan) is an eager participant in the debate on financial regulation and often speaks in the name of the Group of Thirty.

Reputation of the bank, independence and conflicts of interest

The European Central Bank is supposed to be vigilant to any threat to its reputation and independence. The bank also risks being discredited if top level staff have conflicts of interest. Corporate Europe Observatory thinks that Mario Draghi’s membership of the Group of Thirty violates the bank’s own rules and has asked the ECB for a proper explanation. The Bank has not given such an explanation and has refused to acknowledge the problem.

The complaint

In view of the position of the European Central Bank, Corporate Europe Observatory has filed a complaint with the EU Ombudsman. The Ombudsman opened the case in July 2012. The ECB has now replied to the allegations, repeating its earlier arguments. Corporate Europe Observatory will respond to the ECB reply on the 28th of September.

Read more

The methods of the financial lobbyThe financial crisis in 2008 should have been a wake-up call. For many years the private financial sector has been allowed to set the agenda for financial regulation, in the US as well as in the EU. It ended in disaster. As a precautionary measure it is vital that central bankers and politicians keep a distance to the financial lobby. The Group of Thirty is a symbol that this is not the case.What is the Group of Thirty?The Group of Thirty is a club-like organisation whose members are central bankers and prominent bankers from big private banks such as Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan and UBS. It was set up to discuss global banking regulation – and to influence legislation.A lobby group – not merely a think tankThe Group of 30 serves as an important interface between private bankers and central bankers. It’s not merely a place to discuss policy on banking, its stated aim is to have an impact on global regulation. On several occasions, the Group of 30 has come out in favour of proposals which are very similar to the positions put forward by the big private banks. This includes regulation of complicated financial instruments (derivatives) and rules on capital requirements for banks.Draghi is a memberMario Draghi has stepped back and forth between the worlds of public and private banking. He was previously a member of the Group of Thirty when working for Wall Street investment Bank, Goldman Sachs. Now he participates in the activities as President of The European Central Bank. The Group of Thirty regularly puts out reports on controversial issues, and its spokesperson (Jacob Frenkel, JP Morgan) is an eager participant in the debate on financial regulation and often speaks in the name of the Group of Thirty.Reputation of the bank, independence and conflicts of interestThe European Central Bank is supposed to be vigilant to any threat to its reputation and independence. The bank also risks being discredited if top level staff have conflicts of interest. Corporate Europe Observatory thinks that Mario Draghi’s membership of the Group of Thirty violates the bank’s own rules and has asked the ECB for a proper explanation. The Bank has not given such an explanation and has refused to acknowledge the problem.The complaintIn view of the position of the European Central Bank, Corporate Europe Observatory has filed a complaint with the EU Ombudsman. The Ombudsman opened the case in July 2012. The ECB has now replied to the allegations, repeating its earlier arguments. Corporate Europe Observatory will respond to the ECB reply on the 28th of September.Read moreCEO's complaint (July 2012)The ECB’s response (August 2012)CEO's response to the ECB"The President and the private finance club", a briefingTime for Draghi to step down from G30 (article by Corporate Europe Observatory)Lobby to take Presidency of ECB again (article by Corporate Europe Observatory)Website of the Group of Thirty
 

Comments

Submitted by Nathalie (not verified) on

What the hell Paul Krugman does there then ?

Submitted by Kenneth (CEO) (not verified) on

Yes, Krugman's membership and indeed his defence of the Group of Thirty seems surprising. As far as we're concerned we have all the necessary facts on our hands to target the Group of Thirty in the manner described above. So the question should be put to him.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

CEO presents some first reflections on the UK's vote for Brexit.

The current struggle in France over labour law reforms is not just between the Government and trade unions – a European battle is waged. The attacks on social rights stem in no small part from the web of EU-rules dubbed 'economic governance', invented to impose austerity policies on member states.

This summer Greece's financial authorities fined 20 hedge funds for speculating against the Greek economy. Now, the main global lobby group for hedge funds is trying to tweak the EU's rules so they can have a free play in the future.

Civil society groups denounce the Commission's plan for a Capital Markets Union. No lesson has been learnt from the financial crisis, they say.
A few weeks after the May coup against Dilma Rousseff by conservative parties backed by the country's largest corporations, Brazil's “interim” government, led by Michel Temer, signed an emergency loan to the State of Rio de Janeiro to help finance infrastructure for the 2016 Olympics. The bailout was conditional to selling off the State's public water supply and sanitation company, the Companhia Estadual de Águas e Esgotos (Cedae). 

When we interviewed City Councillor and chair of Rio’s Special Committee on the Water Crisis Renato Cinco, in December 2015, he was already warning against such privatisation threats and provided important background information on the water situation in Rio.

Never before has a former European Commission official been criticised as much for his post-EU career as ex-Commission president Barroso upon joining infamous US investment bank Goldman Sachs this summer. Citizens are outraged and evidence already points towards a gross violation of the EU Treaty.

Following the high-level appointment of former European Commission President José Manuel Barroso to Goldman Sachs, NGOs have launched a petition demanding stricter rules for ex-EU commissioners’ revolving door moves.

Corporate Europe Observatory's new report 'A spoonful of sugar' illustrates how the sugar lobby undermines existing laws and fights off much-needed measures that are vital for tackling Europe’s looming obesity crisis.

 
 
 
 
 
-- placeholder --
 
 
 

The corporate lobby tour