Corporate Europe Observatory

Exposing the power of corporate lobbying in the EU

Climate and Energy

For many years now, scientists have warned that we are facing a climate crisis because of our dependency on fossil fuel, and as a result our world is at risk. Instead of taking appropriate action, governments have devised a carbon casino, called carbon trading. In Europe, the UK government teamed up with the oil giant BP to draw up an emissions trading scheme that was by and large taken  by the European Commission as a model. The EU's climate flagship policy, the Emissions Trading System (ETS), is now the world largest carbon market. And it is failing badly.

There is growing evidence that carbon markets are not a solution to the climate crisis. Although in theory carbon trading provides a cheap and efficient way of limiting greenhouse gas emissions within an ever-tightening cap, in practice it has rewarded big polluters with windfall profits. In 2011, carbon prices started to fall, reaching ever-lower levels,  contradicting the carbon trading 'logic' that prices will create scarcity, incentivising corporations to reduce emissions.

The system has also failed to make countries take responsibility for their own emissions, allowing them to offset them by buying permits from the South. This has  caused serious impacts on local communities, including cases where communities have been forced off their land. It also undermines efforts to reduce emissions through other policies.

As European Union (EU) member states consider the implications of environmentally risky shale gas development (fracking), negotiations are underway for a controversial EU–Canada Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA) that would grant investors the right to challenge governments’ decisions to ban and regulate fracking.
On Saturday 20th April, the EU ETS came first place at Climaxi’s Greenwash competition with a big majority, taking 46% of the votes (545 votes). The Greenwash awards, organised by Belgian activist group Climaxi, is meant for organisations or companies who in spite of the green image they cultivate, promote activities which are far from sustainable. The nomination was submitted by Carbon Trade Watch, Corporate Europe Observatory and FERN.
The European Parliament votes tomorrow on the European Commission's proposal to backload 900 million emissions permits within the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS). This vote assumes the EU ETS can be reformed, but ahead of the vote, a new report shows that the problems of the EU ETS are systemic and unresolvable. Keeping this failed system in place would further delay real action for reducing emissions in Europe.
The report "EU ETS myth busting" has been co-published by more than 40 organisations, including Corporate Europe Observatory. It shows that far from being the ‘best tool’ to combat climate change, the EU ETS is inherently too weak to drive the sustainable energy transformation the EU needs in order to stay within global warming limits. It is systemically flawed and cannot be fixed.
Corporate Europe Observatory, Carbon Trade Watch and Fern have nominated the European Commission and the European Union Emissions Trading Scheme for the Greenwash Circus Awards 2013. They argue the EU ETS needs to be exposed for what it is, a subsidy for the worst polluters that the Commission is using to avoid effective climate policies and is irresponsibly expanding it into other regions and areas.
A growing group of civil society organisations is calling on the EU to abolish its Emission Trading System (ETS) to open space for truly effective climate policies. Today they release a joint declaration that highlights the many structural loopholes the ETS is facing, that the proposed reform proposals put forward by EU policy makers will not be able to fix.

A position statement, entitled "Time to scrap the ETS", has been produced to collectively take a stand against the EU-ETS. It aims to help create space for the end of the ETS to be seen as a feasible political option. More than 30 organisations, including Corporate Europe Observatory, have already supported the document. The signatories call on civil society organisations and movements to endorse it and to join the fight to abolish the ETS.

Pages


The Brussels Business: Who runs the EU?

Corporate Europe Observatory

Corporate Europe Observatory (CEO) is a research and campaign group working to expose and challenge the privileged access and influence enjoyed by corporations and their lobby groups in EU policy making.

Read more

Creative Commons License
All content on this website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Subscribe to
Corporate Europe Forum