Corporate Europe Observatory

Exposing the power of corporate lobbying in the EU

  • Dansk
  • NL
  • EN
  • FI
  • FR
  • DE
  • EL
  • IT
  • NO
  • PL
  • PT
  • RO
  • SL
  • ES
  • SV

Don't bet on the commissioner: the case of Karmenu Vella of Malta

Karmenu Vella is a Maltese politician and the country's nominee to be European commissioner, to be responsible for environment, maritime and fisheries. He has been a member of the Maltese parliament since 1976, but that hasn't prevented him from also holding a variety of external business roles at the same time including within the gambling industry. CEO now argues that these recent outside interests make him unsuitable to be a commissioner.

European Commission. Audiovisual services.

According to his own parliamentary website, in 2001 Karmenu Vella was appointed as executive chairman of Corinthia Hotels International. In 2009-10 he served as executive chairman of the Mediterranean Construction Co. Ltd and he was also a founding chairman of the Maltese Turkish Business Council.

Before entering politics, Vella was a bank director and an architect and engineer. According to his most recent declaration of interests, Vella retains a 50 per cent share in his old architecture firm and with his wife he co-owns a company called Multi Joint Projects Co Ltd which he has told CEO he uses “in a few property projects”. He has an extensive property portfolio and large bank assets, boosted by recent property sales.

But it is his recent private sector roles which will raise eyebrows most as, between 2007 and 2013, Vella had an extensive relationship with the Betfair group, acting as “non-executive director on the Betfair Maltese Board” to Betfair Holding (Malta) Limited and Betfair Poker Holdings Limited. He also joined Betfair International Plc on 27 January 2012. Betfair is apparently the world largest internet betting exchange and while it started life as a UK business, its first overseas licence was granted in Malta.

Betfair is not currently in the EU lobby transparency register (although it used to be) but according to the most recently available figures, it employed EU lobby firm Weber Shandwick in 2013 creating €50,000-€100,000 turnover for the lobby firm.

For several years, Vella was also chairman of the Orange Travel Group which is a merger of Maltese travel firms Mondial and SMS Travel. OTG encompasses a number of subsidiaries and associate outbound travel companies, is present in eight countries, and specialises in cruise trips and outbound travel to Malta and elsewhere.

Vella left the OTG on 13 March 2013 which was the same date that he was appointed as… Maltese minister for tourism, a role that he had previously held in 1996-98. He left his Betfair roles on 13 April 2013.

Tourism accounts for 14 per cent of Malta's GDP and perhaps as many as 30 per cent of the Maltese population is directly employed in this sector. Meanwhile, gaming is said to account for 10 per cent of Malta's GDP. In CEO's view, it is pretty shocking that an MP was able to maintain such outside interests whilst apparently not breaking any rules; even more shocking when this MP was then appointed as minister for tourism.

Vella has told CEO that he had no links with either Betfair or the Orange Travel Group during his time as minister for tourism in 2013-14 and he has denied any conflicts of interest saying:

“My Chairmanship with Orange Travel Group and Directorship with Betfair were before my being appointed Minister for Tourism and none of these companies had or have any business related to government.”

In CEO's view, it is inappropriate to nominate as a European commissioner a serving politician who has had such recent links to big business. As a very minimum we hope that MEPs who will shortly grill him on his appointment will seek the following commitments from Vella: a commitment to have no professional or private contacts with any of the companies with which he has been involved and / or their lobby representatives, and a promise to refuse all professional and private contacts with the gambling and tourism industries.

According to his own parliamentary website, in 2001 Karmenu Vella was appointed as executive chairman of Corinthia Hotels International. In 2009-10 he served as executive chairman of the Mediterranean Construction Co. Ltd and he was also a founding chairman of the Maltese Turkish Business Council.Before entering politics, Vella was a bank director and an architect and engineer. According to his most recent declaration of interests, Vella retains a 50 per cent share in his old architecture firm and with his wife he co-owns a company called Multi Joint Projects Co Ltd which he has told CEO he uses “in a few property projects”. He has an extensive property portfolio and large bank assets, boosted by recent property sales.But it is his recent private sector roles which will raise eyebrows most as, between 2007 and 2013, Vella had an extensive relationship with the Betfair group, acting as “non-executive director on the Betfair Maltese Board” to Betfair Holding (Malta) Limited and Betfair Poker Holdings Limited. He also joined Betfair International Plc on 27 January 2012. Betfair is apparently the world largest internet betting exchange and while it started life as a UK business, its first overseas licence was granted in Malta.Betfair is not currently in the EU lobby transparency register (although it used to be) but according to the most recently available figures, it employed EU lobby firm Weber Shandwick in 2013 creating €50,000-€100,000 turnover for the lobby firm.For several years, Vella was also chairman of the Orange Travel Group which is a merger of Maltese travel firms Mondial and SMS Travel. OTG encompasses a number of subsidiaries and associate outbound travel companies, is present in eight countries, and specialises in cruise trips and outbound travel to Malta and elsewhere.Vella left the OTG on 13 March 2013 which was the same date that he was appointed as… Maltese minister for tourism, a role that he had previously held in 1996-98. He left his Betfair roles on 13 April 2013.Tourism accounts for 14 per cent of Malta's GDP and perhaps as many as 30 per cent of the Maltese population is directly employed in this sector. Meanwhile, gaming is said to account for 10 per cent of Malta's GDP. In CEO's view, it is pretty shocking that an MP was able to maintain such outside interests whilst apparently not breaking any rules; even more shocking when this MP was then appointed as minister for tourism.Vella has told CEO that he had no links with either Betfair or the Orange Travel Group during his time as minister for tourism in 2013-14 and he has denied any conflicts of interest saying:“My Chairmanship with Orange Travel Group and Directorship with Betfair were before my being appointed Minister for Tourism and none of these companies had or have any business related to government.”In CEO's view, it is inappropriate to nominate as a European commissioner a serving politician who has had such recent links to big business. As a very minimum we hope that MEPs who will shortly grill him on his appointment will seek the following commitments from Vella: a commitment to have no professional or private contacts with any of the companies with which he has been involved and / or their lobby representatives, and a promise to refuse all professional and private contacts with the gambling and tourism industries.
 

Comments

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

CEO's immediate reaction to the latest revelations from the team behind the Panama Leaks.

The Juncker Commission last week informed the European Ombudsman that it would refer Barroso’s appointment as chairman of Goldman Sachs to its Ad hoc Ethical Committee. But what is the Ad hoc Ethical Committee, who sits on it and what is it likely to say?

Corporate Europe Observatory welcomes the results of the European Ombudsman's investigation into the Commission's handling of the revolving doors and promised a further investigation into the Commission's approach.

Corporate Europe Observatory's media reaction to the European Commission referring its former president Barroso's Goldman Sachs appointment to an ethics committee.

The Commission is set to announce its proposal for a new ‘mandatory’ lobby transparency register next week. During the Summer, the Commission made public the input it received via consultation on the topic. Besides a general call from public and civil society to boost transparency systems, they also showed corporate lobby groups and trade associations’ spin, promoting transparency values while recommending limited implementation, loopholes and toothless management.

CEO's immediate reaction to the latest revelations from the team behind the Panama Leaks.

The European Commission is about to propose a regulation on acrylamide, a dangerous contaminant formed in many starchy foods when cooked at high temperatures. But the regulation itself consists in referring to codes of best practices developed by lobby groups representing the food industry.

A new report on the Comprehensive Economic Trade Agreement (CETA) reveals how the trade deal could make EU member states vulnerable to costly lawsuits from North American investors that threaten public interest.

 
 
 
 
 
-- placeholder --
 
 
 

The corporate lobby tour