New research by Corporate Europe Observatory traces how financial and car industry lobbies have slipped their wishes into draft EU rules for the sale of bundled and repackaged car loans. ‘Securitisation’, the financial tool at the root of the recent financial crisis, looks set to be promoted by EU parliamentarians in a plenary vote this Thursday.
Even though the triggers of the last crash remain at the core of this financial instrument for bundling and selling loans, EU decision makers and bankers have been promoting it as a growth booster for the European market.
Published today, “Driving Financial Markets the Wrong Way” takes a closer look at the way corporate lobbyists have led EU governments and parliamentarians to forget the lessons of the 2008 crash. It reveals car manufacturers’ proposals for lax rules regarding the sale of bundled and repackaged car loans, most of which were accepted at the so-called ‘trilogue’ negotiations between the EU Commission, the Parliament and the Council. In the US, such loose regulation has already allowed the development of a sizable ‘subprime’ car loan bubble, which threatens consumers’ personal finance and the banking sector at large.
Instead of heeding the devastating track record of securitisation, European legislators appear set to loosen rules for these kinds of transactions, rather than bolster the stability of the EU financial market and protect citizens against predatory lending.
Corporate Europe Observatory’s financial policy researcher Kenneth Haar said:
“The EU is about to promote the very same financial instrument that was at the centre of the devastating financial crisis a few years ago. Corporate lobbyists have tried to wash securitisation clean of its terrible track record and its reputation as ’public enemy no.1’, but it remains a very dangerous tool that needs to be strictly regulated.
”At the last moment, the car industry lobby managed to have the draft rules considerably weakened. The last financial crash aside, a quick look across the Atlantic also shows where lax laws on securities trading lead: in the US, we see a car loans bubble that could burst anytime”.
Kenneth Haar, email@example.com, +45 236 006 31
Notes to editors:
- On Thursday, 26 October 2017, the European Parliament plenary will vote on a legislative package supposed to liberalise trading in securities, which will make it easier to bundle loans and sell them on. Critics have highlighted that the proposals risk to repeat the mistakes that led to the financial crisis in 2008.
The package consists of two proposals, one is a series of changes to the existing Capital Requirements Regulation, and another is on 'Simple, Transparent and Standardised' securitisation. In short, if a security (for instance a bundle of car loans) meets certain criteria, the capital buffer required to invest in them is smaller.
Both proposals have been negotiated between Parliament, Council and Commission since late 2016. A compromise was reached on 30 May between delegates from the three institutions. The fact that the European Parliament gave way on key issues during the talks may have an impact on the outcome on the vote.
- Consult the central lobby document submitted by the the car industry during the negotiations between Commission, Council and Parliament, which was obtained as part of an access to documents request. [https://www.asktheeu.org/en/request/4148/response/13681/attach/21/35%20VDA%20CCFA%20BDA%20Position%20EU%20STS%20CRR%2025012017%20Redacted.pdf]
- This report on securitisation in tranches by the Bank of International Settlements underlines that ’tranching’ , securitisation in layers with different charactesristics, cannot be reconciled with the ’simple, transparent and standardised’ nature of the securities eligible for preferential treatment under the new EU rules. [http://www.bis.org/publ/qtrpdf/r_qt1412f.pdf]