• Dansk
  • NL
  • EN
  • FI
  • FR
  • DE
  • EL
  • IT
  • NO
  • PL
  • PT
  • RO
  • SL
  • ES
  • SV

EU Parliament emissions trading ‘compromise’ is godsend for polluters, says CEO

The EU Emissions Trading System (ETS) is another step closer to handing out billions in free pollution permits to polluters, following this morning’s vote in the European Parliament’s Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety (ENVI).

The ENVI vote suggests an increased share of free allowances within the ETS scheme that could be worth over €175 billion to some of Europe’s biggest polluters, according to analysis by Corporate Europe Observatory, whose Carbon Welfare report on the reform of the ETS was released last week.

Responding to the vote, Corporate Europe Observatory’s climate policy researcher Belén Balanyá, commented:

“The proposed emissions trading reforms would continue to hand billions of euros in carbon welfare to some of the continent’s biggest polluting industries. It’s scandalous that the EU’s main climate policy is to prop up polluters rather than encouraging a low-carbon transition.”

As well as providing more free allowances to industry, the ENVI vote made a number of other concessions demanded by industry lobbyists. A key industry demand that has been included is the allocation of a three per cent share of auction revenues to subsidise the electricity costs of big polluters.

In return, the ENVI Committee agreed to proposals that increase the overall emissions goal for the ETS to a figure closer to the EU’s existing 2050 goal, as well as agreeing a proposal that could remove up to 1 billion surplus permits from the system, while leaving over a billion more in place.

Climate and energy policy researcher Oscar Reyes, who co-authored Corporate Europe Observatory’s Carbon Welfare report, added:

“This ‘compromise’ deal is a godsend for polluters. Industry lobbying contributed to a huge surplus of pollution permits, which has collapsed the carbon price. Now industry has managed to extract a promise of more free permits as a condition for reducing a surplus that it helped to create. The merry-go-round of handouts for polluters has to stop.”

Notes to Editors

  • The Commission proposed auctioning 57 per cent of emissions permits. The Parliament amendments agreed today could reduce this figure by up to 5 per cent. This includes changing the basis for what counts as auctioning.

  • For more detail on this and on the ways industry lobbyists have pressed for these measures, see Corporate Europe Observatory’s latest climate and energy policy report:

    Carbon Welfare: how big polluters plan to profit from EU Emissions Trading Reform

Contact details

Oscar Reyes, oereye@gmail.com,  +34 626 216 311

Belén Balanyá, belen@corporateeurope.org, +31 633 309 0386


CEO welcomes the very strongly worded final ruling by European Ombudsman Emily O'Reilly in her inquiry into the Commission's implementation of UN rules for contacts with tobacco industry lobbyists.

CEO joined forces with nine other civil society organisations working for equality, non-discrimination, transparent decision-making and strong ethics rules: in an open letter to the European Parliament we urge MEPs to oppose Oettinger’s appointment as the Comission’s head of human resources.

After nine months of hearings, the draft report of the EU Parliament's inquiry into the Dieselgate scandal has it black on white: the European Commission and EU member states had known since 2004-05 that diesel cars' nitrogen oxide emissions were far above legal limits - yet neither took action.

Our new report shows how industry lobbies present employee protection against work-related cancers as an 'unnecessary' burden on companies, and explains which tactics have been used to weaken and delay the European Union's revision of the Carcinogens and Mutagens Directive.

Subscribe to our newsletter